Should teachers and students be friends?

Standard

Should teachers really be friends with their students?

I don’t mean friend as in friendly, kind, accepting, etc. —  I mean friend as in the kind of friend that you hang out with outside of class, the friend you call at night to tell about your latest accomplishment, the kind of friend that you have over on your birthday. Should teachers be this kind of friend to their students?

My opinions on this subject stem from an experience in high school. Not my own experience, rather the experience of a sideline viewer.

A student I knew in high school was close friends with her teacher. They hung out, played volleyball and basketball, called each other to talk about whatever was on their mind, went out to dinner — the kind of things all good friends do. But this student was also in the class of this teacher, and their friendship proved a negative to their classroom interaction.

The student could get away with things that no other student could, because the teacher was her friend. The student could speak to that teacher like no other student should, because the teacher was her friend. And everybody watching this happen commented negatively about how their friendship was spilling over into the classroom. Other students resented the fact that this one student could do, or say anything she wanted and get away with it.

I was bothered greatly by the affect that this student/teacher friendship had on my class (I was in the class with them both.) I vividly remember the student walking away from a major fight with the teacher (which took place in front of everyone else in the class) and not even receiving detention, when any other student would have received several days of suspension.  I lost respect for both individuals that year.

So I ask again, should teachers be this kind of friend to their students? I don’t think so. I realize that there might be a few exceptions, but in general, I think teacher’s must retain a proper student-teacher relationship that doesn’t allow for partiality or other issues that might work their way into the classroom. I believe this is particularly important on the high school level.

To read an interesting article written by a teacher on this subject, check out http://plpnetwork.com/2011/09/23/should-teachers-friend-their-students/.

Advertisements

4 responses »

  1. I totally agree that they shouldn’t be! I’ve seen partiality in the classroom and it drove me insane. (I was on the wrong side of the paritality) Good thoughts

  2. I completely agree Mary, I don’t think that kind of friendship is appropriate in that situation. It leaves to much opportunity for either individual to abuse it.

  3. I don’t think I’ve ever been buds with one of my teachers–nor do I want to…they’re teachers! Of course, it’s always going to be different for those teachers who have known the student their whole life, especially outside of school. But the teacher has the responsibility to enforce rules equally, no matter what the relationship is. I agree, especially in high school, this could be a big problem.

  4. Friendships like these should be happening in a classroom setting. There is no getting around the fact that favoritism will be shown not only dealing with disciplinary action, but also how the teacher grades that student’s papers.

    If a student and a teacher are close friends, the best solution would be for the student to take classes where that teacher does not teach, but that won’t also be an option. Some sort of understanding would have to take place between the two to differentiate between their relationship inside and outside of the classroom.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s